Washington DC USA - July 3 2017: Federal Trade Commission seal sign and logo in downtown

FTC’s Amended Negative Option Rule Faces Regulatory Hurdles, Delayed Implementation Expected

Mark Roth reports on recent ALJ decision that is pushing the FTC rule’s enactment to potentially late 2024, amidst economic impact concerns.

FTC warns against subscription tricks and traps, steps up enforcement


Many have been asking about the status of the amended FTC Negative Option Rule and when it is likely to go into effect.  


Still don’t know for sure, though not any time soon given a recent decision by the ALJ overseeing the three informal hearings conducted earlier this year on the FTC rule-making process, resulting in a setback for the FTC and greater scrutiny of the impact conclusions it made in the proposed rule.  My best guesstimate at this point…late Q3, possibly Q4, but in any event, likely before any possible administration change.

The Full Tea

While the Vegas over/under has for some time been a late spring/early summer 2024 effective date, the Informal Hearings on the rule-making process conducted earlier this year (Jan 16Jan 31, and Feb 14) appears to have pushed that out a bit, the latest development being a “Recommended Decision” issued by the ALJ on April 12 (but not made public until April 25) finding that (i) the new rule will impact the US economy by more than $100 MM,and (ii) the record does not establish what the record-keeping and disclosure costs associated with the proposed rule will be.

Why is this important?  Because under the relatively obscure federal Congressional Review Act of 1996 (come get geeky with me!), all federal agencies are required to submit final rules to the Government Accountability Office (GAO) before they go into effect, but rules that meet the $100 MM impact threshold are considered a “major rule,” in which case GAO must prepare a report to Congress “on whether an agency, in promulgating a major rule, has complied with the regulatory process.”  Since the FTC summarily concluded (with literally no evidence) that the proposed rule did not meet that threshold, the ALJ decision that it would, based on testimony offered by various industry trade groups during the hearings, was effectively a body blow to the FTC.  I have heard from various sources that following the ALJ Recommended Decision (is that oxymoron?), the FTC has been reaching out to several companies and others seeking data on their estimated costs for complying with the proposed rule and the financial impact on them and consumers.  So…Recommended Decision = Rulemaking Speedbump.

In addition to requiring GAO to issue a report to Congress, it also allows Congress to reject or rescind a final “major” rule.  And whereas a non “major” rule may take effect as it ordinarily would following posting in the Federal Register (FR), a “major” rule may take effect no earlier than 60 calendar days after Congress receives the GAO report or is published in the FR, whichever is later.

So…back to timing…the CRA requires the GAO to issue its report to each house of Congress no later than 15 calendar days after a rule is submitted to GAO or published in the FR.  Since the ALJ deemed the rule to be “major,” it can not, as noted above, go into effect until at least 60 days after the GAO report is sent to Congress, which means we could be looking at an effective date up to 75 days after the rule is published in the FR, and that’s assuming Congress doesn’t challenge or reject it.

We are tracking the FR to see when the final rule is published, which will then start the clock on the GAO report and when Congress must review the rule.  Stay tuned!

Up Next

Register Now For Email Subscription News Updates!

Search this site

You May Be Interested in:

Join us to master the latest subscription business strategies, from emerging payment trends

Log In

Join Subscription Insider!

Get unlimited access to info, strategy, how-to content, trends, training webinars, and 10 years of archives on growing a profitable subscription business. We cover the unique aspects of running a subscription business including compliance, payments, marketing, retention, market strategy and even choosing the right tech.

Already a Subscription Insider member? 

Access these premium-exclusive features

(Normally $57)

Perfect To Try A Membership!
$ 35

(Normally $395)

$16.25 Per Month, Paid Annually
$ 195

(10 Members)

Normally Five Members
$ 997

Interested in a team license? For up to 5 team members, order here.
Need more seats? Please contact us here.